Cotten’s Barbecue – CLOSED

226 W. Bitters Rd.
San Antonio, TX 78216

Phone: (210) 403-2277
Hours: CLOSED
Website: www.cottensbarbecue.com
Facebook: www.facebook.com/Cottens.Barbecue.SanAntonio

Opened 2013
Method Gas-fired Rotisserie with Mesquite

TMBBQ Rating: 2.5

TMBBQ Buzz

Comments from our joint finder app.
Stopped in on a weekday at 12:40 & was immersed in the "you're at a GREAT Texas BBQ joint" feeling immediately. Cars parked up and down the street (like it seems to be a most great places there is little parking). I saw some outside picnic tables with people from all walks of life talking and eating. I made it inside and found about 4 tables and not too bad of a line. The lady taking orders (& everyone else) were super friendly. I felt like a regular. I ordered the 3 meat and a table opened up so I ate there inside. The line came by my table so I was able to tell from the talk all the first timers who were in line. The returners were giving them pointers on what sausage, ribs & sides to pick. I got moist brisket which had a black bark and plenty of smoke. Great flavor and unlike some have said it had a good salty taste. The spicy sausage looked dry but I was surprised at how tender and good it was. It snapped when you ate it and had an excellent flavor. The ribs I got were St Louis style and although the meat was firm it would pull off the bone in one big delicious piece. I am definitely becoming a rib man. It had a pretty pink ring and was moist was a brisket rub kind of flavor. I don't line multi meat plates. I'd rather get more of 1 or 2 meats but at Gatlin's I don't know what meat I'd eliminate. I ordered it to go so I could take the left overs but there were none! My choice for BBQ in Houston.
Hank Mangum @ Gatlin’s BBQ, 2014-04-18 08:37:56
pretty darn good
rgv @ Longoria’s BBQ, 2014-04-17 13:51:33
Simple, great sandwiches and plates, beef is tender and perfectly cooked. Fresh, crisp cole slaw and great tater salad. Beautiful Texan place with a handful of small tables on the porch and some more in the yard out front. Been there twice, and will return. Perfect for a lunch when out bicycling!
Trond Smestad @ Pop’s Pit BBQ, 2014-04-17 13:43:34
Pound of ribs they were perfection beans and tater salad
doug_wallace @ Angelo’s, 2014-04-16 14:07:00
Place is closed...thank god
Brad Golub @ Duke’s Smokehouse, 2014-04-15 20:28:17
Still the best in Lockhart and second best in central Texas.
Brad Golub @ Black’s Barbecue, 2014-04-15 11:35:24
Fantastic Beef Rib and Beef Brisket
Omar Lemus @ Black’s Barbecue, 2014-04-14 16:29:35
It saddens me to hear the words brisket and bbq sauce in the same sentence.
Larry Broome @ , 2014-04-13 20:21:27
More Buzz →

Reviews

September 10, 2013

Update: This joint is permanently CLOSED. 2013: This is the second in a dual review. It’s rare to find two barbecue joints with food so similar to one another, but Cotten’s Catering in Calallen and Cotten’s Barbecue in San Antonio are nearly dead ringers. It all goes back to 1947 when Joe Cotten starting selling barbecue in Robstown just south of Corpus Christi. The joint was host to presidents and celebrities and was one of…